Gulf Financial Free Zones Update, 19 October to 18 November 2026

In the ADGM, two former chief executives of the NMC Group blamed each other for an eight-year fraud, but the Court found against both. Two siblings found that a court in Shanghai had already shut a door they wanted the ADGM to close. Elsewhere, a three-month window to challenge an award, a second appeal on costs and an employee’s final pay each proved less negotiable than someone hoped.

In the DIFC, the Chief Justice made it plain that for an award made in a DIFC-seated arbitration, Article 41 of the Arbitration Law is the only way out. A subcontractor that spent its time suing in Abu Dhabi and Dubai instead found nothing left when the award came to be enforced. Two costs orders from H.E. Justice Mark Pelling, read together, set out how the DIFC Courts now assess a bill: guideline rates, no conventional percentage, and US Prime on dollar costs. And Bank of India’s DIFC branch learned that documents held by its sister branches in India and Singapore are, prima facie, within its control.

In the ADGM, after a trial that ran from March to July, Justice Sir Andrew Smith found Dr Shetty and Mr Manghat party to the fraud that brought down the NMC Group, with US$ 5,397 million as the starting point for their contributions. A brother and sister seeking to freeze their father’s cryptocurrency found that the preservation orders they already had in Shanghai were why they could not obtain one.

In the QFC, the Appellate Division set a stiffer test for second appeals against costs assessments, and more than 100 pages of submissions did not get the applicants through it. A consultant who kept working without an agreed price was paid a reasonable sum for it. At first instance, the Court rejected an argument that the 2021 law creating the Investment and Trade Court had quietly taken away its jurisdiction over insurance disputes, and a start-up was told that an employee’s final pay is not a bargaining chip. We also catch up on two Appellate Division decisions from July, and on last month’s young consultant, who has now won his INR 8,000.

On the rulebook side, the three DFSA instruments we flagged last month take effect on 1 January 2027. They confine the Islamic Finance Rules to firms that hold themselves out as Shari’a compliant, and say when that happens. They also move Takaful disclosure back into COB and trim some rules for credit rating agencies.

DIFC

Court of Appeal

Oberlin v Ovidiu (ARB 008/2026, link)

DIFC Court of Appeal, 22 October 2026. H.E. Chief Justice Wayne Martin, on a referral under RDC 44.8. ARB 008/2026. Parties anonymised.

If you agree to arbitrate in the DIFC, the DIFC is where you challenge the award. This subcontractor tried Abu Dhabi and Dubai first.

It had agreed to DIFC-seated arbitration, then sued in Abu Dhabi instead. It carried on in defiance of an emergency arbitrator’s order and repeated DIFC anti-suit injunctions. Having lost the arbitration, it tried to set the award aside in the Dubai Courts. When the contractor enforced the award in the DIFC, the subcontractor applied to set enforcement aside under Article 44 of the DIFC Arbitration Law.

Permission to appeal was refused. For an award made in a DIFC-seated arbitration, Article 41 is the only route of recourse. A party that made, or could have made, an Article 41 application cannot resist enforcement on the Article 44(1)(a) grounds. Only arbitrability and UAE public policy survive, and the subcontractor raised neither.

If the seat is the DIFC, the three months allowed by Article 41 are the whole of the challenge. Spend them in another court, and they are gone.

VTB Bank PJSC v Kuanyshev and others (CA 013/2026)

Last month we said we would report the contemnors’ appeal against their sanctions, which was listed for hearing on 21 October. When we last checked the DIFC Courts’ register, on 16 November, no decision had been published. We will report it when it appears.

Court of First Instance

Keshav Global Trading LLC v ETG Commodities Holding Limited (CFI 069/2024; non-party respondent Bank of India, DIFC Branch; link)

Court of First Instance, 27 October 2026. H.E. Justice Sir Jeremy Cooke. CFI 069/2024. Decided on the papers.

Back to the Bank of India’s DIFC branch, which we last saw being hurried along on the timetable. Faced with an application for production of documents, the branch argued that documents held by the bank’s branches in India and Singapore were beyond its control.

The Court disagreed. Control is tested as it is for disclosure generally, and a branch should, prima facie, be able to obtain documents from other branches of the same bank. Separate databases do not change that.

A short order, but one to keep to hand when seeking documents from a bank in the DIFC. The starting point is what the bank holds, not just what sits in the branch.

Costs

Peyton v Paul (ARB 051/2025, link) and Penelope v Phoebe (ARB 019/2023, link)

Orders of H.E. Justice Mark Pelling, 29 October 2026 (ARB 051/2025) and 21 October 2026 (ARB 019/2023, ARB 032/2026 and ARB 033/2026). Parties anonymised.

Read together, these two orders are a short manual on how the DIFC Courts now assess costs. Those who draft statements of costs may want to sit down.

On the standard basis, recoverable costs are the lowest sum the receiving party could reasonably have spent to have its case presented proficiently. Time is allowed at the lower of the rate charged and the Registrar’s guideline rate. There is no conventional DIFC recovery percentage to apply to a bill, and what the paying party spent on its own side is no yardstick.

Two further points. A failed challenge to an award will not readily be labelled totally without merit, because that would deter arguable challenges. And interest on costs in dollars runs at US Prime, not 9%.

Build budgets and statements of costs to the guideline rates, and properly break down work on documents. Do not expect to recover for four fee earners at a two-hour hearing.

ADGM

NMC Healthcare Ltd (in administration) and others v Shetty and others; Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank PJSC v Manghat [2026] ADGMCFI 0027 (PDF)

Court of First Instance, Commercial and Civil Division, 5 November 2026. Justice Sir Andrew Smith. ADGMCFI-2022-299, ADGMCFI-2020-020 and ADGMCFI-2022-111. Trial between 23 March and 3 July 2026. Mr Bankim Thanki KC and Mr Henry King KC, leading a team instructed by Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan UK LLP, for the administrators and the NMC companies; Mr Rajesh Pillai KC, leading a team instructed by Holman Fenwick Willan LLP, for ADCB; Mr Kajetan Wandowicz, instructed by Bishwajit Dubey, for Dr Shetty; Mr Patrick Hennessey, instructed by Mr Manghat, for Mr Manghat. Bank of Baroda, represented by Mr Harish Salve KC and a team instructed by Baker & McKenzie LLP, settled towards the end of the trial.

A trial that ran from March to July, a judgment of 209 pages, and a starting figure of US$ 5,397 million.

It was common ground that the NMC Group, whose parent, NMC Health plc, was an English company, was the victim of a massive fraud between April 2012 and April 2020. Money was taken out of the group, and its accounts overstated its assets and turnover. The question was who was involved. Dr Bavaguthu Raghuram Shetty, a director and until 2017 the chief executive, said he knew nothing and was himself a victim of Mr Manghat and other managers. Mr Prasanth Manghat, also a former chief executive, said Dr Shetty and the other principal shareholders were its true architects and beneficiaries.

The Court found against both. Dr Shetty knowingly received large sums improperly taken from the group, directly and indirectly, and used them to buy personal assets. He used bank facilities he knew were supported by securities the accounts did not properly disclose. As a director, he let the group publish accounts that hid its true position, and in March 2019 he helped hide its borrowings from EY. Mr Manghat knew of and facilitated the misappropriations and knew the accounts hid the group’s true borrowing. The judge found he had the leading role in operating the fraud. He rejected Mr Manghat’s claim that he was subservient to others, as that was unlikely for the chief executive of a FTSE 100 company.

Both are liable to make contributions for fraudulent trading under section 251 of the ADGM Insolvency Regulations 2022, and to the companies under Articles 282 and 285 of the UAE Civil Code and for unjust enrichment. Mr Manghat is also liable to ADCB. The starting point for the contributions is US$ 5,397 million, the experts’ agreed figure for the increase in the net deficiency to creditors after 30 April 2012. The judge rejected any sliding scale of culpability; each man is to bear the full consequences of the insolvency. The absence of any connection with the ADGM during the fraud was not a reason to reduce the contributions, since conduct of this kind would be actionable under any developed system of law. Instead of statutory interest, the contributions will carry a quasi-interest uplift. ADCB has established damages of about US$ 1,022m in outstanding debt and about US$ 169m in lost profit, less credits of about US$ 30m.

The judge also said, without needing to decide it, that a contribution for fraudulent trading might properly exceed the increase in the net deficiency. That is obiter, but office-holders will note it.

Nothing is final yet. The amounts, interest, costs, and the defendants’ claims against each other all await a further hearing. It is a first-instance decision, so watch for an appeal.

A judgment of this size and importance needs more room than a monthly note can give it. We will publish a fuller article on it once the further hearing has fixed the orders.

Wo Qi v Wo Weidong and others; Quan (James) Wo v Wo Weidong and others [2026] ADGMCFI 0029 (PDF)

Court of First Instance, Commercial and Civil Division, 12 November 2026. Justice Paul Heath KC. ADGMCFI-2026-646 and ADGMCFI-2026-647. Heard 25 September and 5 November 2026. Mr Jamie Riley KC and Ms Clarissa Jones, instructed by Hadef & Partners LLC, for the claimants; Mr Rajesh Pillai KC and Mr James McWilliams, instructed by AlAidarous Advocates & Legal Consultants LLC, for the first to third defendants; no appearance for the fourth defendant.

A family dispute, two Shanghai properties, a good deal of cryptocurrency, and claims worth about US$ 77m that were cut in China to about US$ 1,500 each without anyone telling the ADGM Court.

A brother and sister sued their father and mother in Shanghai over the proceeds of sale of two properties, claiming about US$ 14m and US$ 63m. In the ADGM, on notice, they sought freezing orders over cryptocurrency said to be held for their father by two Cayman companies he controls, in accounts with Nest Clearing, which operates the Binance exchange in the ADGM. They also sought disclosure orders, including against Nest Clearing.

Before the first hearing, the father’s evidence revealed that the siblings’ PRC lawyer had applied to reduce each claim to about CNY 10,000, and had not mentioned this in his evidence to the ADGM Court. The siblings asked for an adjournment. Over the following weeks, their PRC lawyer applied, apparently without instructions, to withdraw the claims. The Shanghai court upheld the father’s jurisdiction challenge and transferred the case to another district court, and the siblings filed fresh claims at the original values.

A good arguable case survived, although the judge called the father’s approach "overly technical"; it was enough to point to a factual foundation on which a claim can be pursued abroad. Assuming the facts would be proved, the siblings had a good arguable case for the full sums on a property-based claim, regardless of what the Chinese courts did with the procedural tangle. Nobody argued that cryptocurrency on an ADGM exchange cannot be frozen, and the judge proceeded on the basis that it can.

However, the applications failed on risk of dissipation. On the evidence, moving assets around his businesses was how the father had long done business. More to the point, the Shanghai court’s preservation orders already attached shares with a registered value of about US$93m, more than the US$77m claimed. With that protection in place, and no sign that assets had been moved while the applications were pending, there was no plausible evidential basis for a real risk. Without a freezing order, a disclosure order against Nest Clearing would have been fishing.

The judge called the failure to tell the Court about the reduced claims a matter of the utmost concern. He did not suggest it was deliberate, and said he would not have dismissed the applications on that ground alone. Costs, including whether they should be on the indemnity basis, are reserved.

Two lessons, then. Before asking the ADGM Court to freeze assets in aid of foreign proceedings, look at what is already frozen at home. Adequate protection there can defeat the application. Also keep the Court told of every step abroad that changes the picture, however tactical it seemed at the time.

The ADGM Courts’ register lists no Court of Appeal judgment in the period. The most recent is still [2025] ADGMCA 0003, of 7 October 2025.

QFC

Appellate Division

Al-Nasr and Al-Maadeed v Nexus Financial Services WLL [2026] QIC (A) 16 (PDF)

QFC Civil and Commercial Court, Appellate Division, 22 October 2026. Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd (President), Justice Chelva Rajah SC and Justice Tan Sri Nallini Pathmanathan. CTFIC0032/2024 and CTFIC0033/2024. Said Al-Mansoori Law Office for the applicants; the judgment does not record who acted for the respondent.

Nexus Financial Services appears for the second month running, this time in a long-running investment dispute and on a point that reaches every litigant in the QFC Court.

Two investors lost their claims, and then failed to get permission to appeal. They then challenged the Registrar’s assessment of the costs they had to pay: about USD 250,000 in all, against combined claims of over USD 22m. The First Instance Circuit upheld the assessment. The investors sought a further appeal, with more than 100 pages of submissions, most of them re-arguing the merits.

Permission was refused, and the Court took the chance to set a test for second appeals. Where the First Instance Circuit has reviewed a decision of the Registrar, the Appellate Division will now give permission only if the ordinary test is met and the appeal raises an important point of principle or practice, or there is some other compelling reason to hear it. The application must identify that point at the outset, in clear terms, or it will simply be dismissed. Along the way, the Court confirmed that the Registrar is a judicial officer exercising a judicial function when assessing costs, and that a judge reviewing the assessment reviews it rather than starting again.

Costs assessments in the QFC Court are now close to final once a judge has reviewed them. Anyone thinking of going further needs a point of general importance, and needs to lead with it. A hundred pages will not do the work of one good paragraph.

El Jed v Barzah Capital LLC [2026] QIC (A) 17 (PDF)

QFC Civil and Commercial Court, Appellate Division, 26 October 2026. Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd (President), Justice Her Honour Frances Kirkham CBE and Justice Fritz Brand. CTFIC0049/2026. Both parties self-represented.

A consultant did a first phase of work for an agreed QAR 36,000, then carried on with a second phase at the client’s request. Nobody agreed a price for the second phase. The client’s position was that, with no terms agreed, it owed nothing. The small claims judge disagreed, and awarded QAR 36,000.

The Appellate Division refused permission to appeal. There was ample evidence of an agreement by conduct to pay a reasonable amount, which is what Article 51 of the QFC Contract Regulations 2005 provides, and valuing the second phase by reference to the first was open to the judge. The Court also restated its light-touch approach to small claims appeals decided on the papers.

Ask for a second helping, and expect a bill.

First Instance

Nasser Bin Khaled Al Thani and Sons Holding WLL v Sharq Insurance LLC [2026] QIC (F) 72 (PDF)

QFC Civil and Commercial Court, First Instance Circuit, 28 October 2026. Justice Tan Sri Nallini Pathmanathan. CTFIC0064/2026. The Al-Musllam Law Firm for the claimant; Noora Sarhan Lawyers & Legal Consultants for the defendant.

It began with a fire-damaged concrete pump. It ended with the QFC Court’s jurisdiction over onshore contracts intact. We think this is the QFC decision of the month.

A contractor outside the QFC sued its QFC insurer. The insurer said the Court had no jurisdiction. Law No. 21 of 2021, which created the Investment and Trade Court, gives that court exclusive jurisdiction over disputes relating to insurance companies. As the later law, the insurer said, it had superseded Gateway 4 of the QFC Law.

The Court rejected the argument. Law No. 21 of 2021 allocates work among the State’s ordinary courts and says nothing about the QFC Court, which sits outside that system. Gateway 4 is the special provision and Law No. 21 the general one, and a later general law does not quietly override an earlier special one. Read the other way, the 2021 Law would have removed most of the QFC Court’s work without mentioning it.

The argument would have reached well beyond insurance, since the Investment and Trade Court’s list covers commercial contracts generally. For now, contracts between QFC entities and onshore parties stay within the QFC Court’s reach. This is a first-instance decision, so watch for an appeal.

Fahda v ACDAC12 LLC [2026] QIC (F) 71 (PDF)

QFC Civil and Commercial Court, First Instance Circuit (small claims), 27 October 2026. Justice Tan Sri Nallini Pathmanathan. CTFIC0066/2026. Both parties self-represented.

A start-up’s scientist resigned after two months and was paid nothing. The employer said payment had to wait for exit clearance, a handover, a new confidentiality agreement and Qatari bank details. It also counterclaimed for notice and recruitment costs.

All of that failed. Article 25(2) of the QFC Employment Regulations requires outstanding wages to be paid within 30 days of termination, and the duty is unconditional, so none of those things could hold up payment. By accepting the resignation on the date requested, the employer waived the notice period. And the employer’s own letters to banks, confirming his start date, settled the one factual dispute.

QFC employers, take note: final pay is not a bargaining chip.

Catching up

J v K [2026] QIC (A) 13 (CTFIC0064/2025, 26 July 2026; Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, President, Justice Sir William Blair and Justice Dr Hassan Al-Sayed; PDF). Earlier in the J v K litigation, the company asked to move the August trial because its chosen counsel was unavailable. Permission was refused. The trial date had been fixed more than two months ahead, which was ample time to instruct someone else, and any duplicated cost was, in the Court’s words, “wholly insignificant” against the sums in issue (para 12). The Court also declined to swap in a different panel to fit a later date. Counsel of choice is a factor, not a trump card.

Aegis Services LLC v Bakertilly Advisory Services LLC [2026] QIC (A) 14 (CTFIC0012/2026, 27 July 2026; Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, President, Justice Dr Muna Al-Marzouqi and Justice Dr Talal Al-Emadi; PDF). A QAR 6,500 small claim for ISO 27001 certification work. The paying party had alleged poor work, fraud and forgery at first instance, but produced nothing to answer the detailed reply. On appeal, it tried to add new documents, including a proposal dated 15 April 2026 that it could have produced the first time round. Permission was refused: evidence belongs before the First Instance Circuit, and fresh evidence on appeal is admitted only in limited circumstances, none of which arose. Fraud and forgery are large words for a QAR 6,500 claim, and they need evidence to match.

DG v Play Rivals Gaming LLC [2026] QIC (F) 59 (CTFIC0051/2026, 20 September 2026; Justice Tan Sri Nallini Pathmanathan; PDF). Last month we reported that a minor’s claim for unpaid consultancy fees survived a strike-out, with his father brought in as litigation guardian. This is the sequel, decided on the papers, and the young consultant won. The company ended his consultancy and withheld INR 8,000, a month’s fee, as a penalty for “material misconduct”. As this was a consultancy and not employment, the Court asked a contractual question under the QFC Contract Regulations 2005, not whether the company’s process had been fair (paras 17 to 20). The company relied on an exception, so it had to prove the misconduct (para 24). It proved that he had posted that he would not work with anyone who worked with two people it said were its community representatives, about two hours after his manager warned him of consequences. It did not prove the harm it pleaded. Its own public statements blamed the game’s publisher for the disruption, and the rest of its evidence was, it said, “available to be produced to the Court upon request” (para 12). That was not enough (paras 36 to 39). The INR 8,000 is payable with interest at 5%, and the company’s claim for its own staff’s time at QAR 200 an hour was refused (para 41). If you plead harm, exhibit the proof.

Rulebooks and Practice Directions

DFSA: holding out, Takaful and credit ratings (notice of amendments; instruments No. 444, No. 445 and No. 446)

Rule-making instruments of the DFSA Board, made 1 October 2026 under Article 23 of the Regulatory Law 2004, following Consultation Papers 172 and 174. In force 1 January 2027.

Last month we promised to say what the three January instruments do. Most of the change is in the Islamic Finance Rules (IFR), and the theme is holding out.

From January, IFR applies to an Authorised Person that holds itself out as carrying on a Financial Service in or from the DIFC in accordance with Shari’a. The words covering a person who simply carries on such a service go (IFR 1.1.1(1)(a)). A new rule says when a firm holds itself out: when it presents all or part of its business as Shari’a compliant, provides a service in relation to a product it holds out as Islamic, or manages a Fund it holds out that way (IFR 1.1.1(2)). New guidance gives examples, such as calling a service “halal” or saying it follows the directions of a Shari’a Supervisory Board. It also offers some comfort. A firm does not hold itself out just by providing a service in respect of a product someone else markets as Islamic, unless it produced or approved that material, or by calling a sukuk a sukuk in a product list. The chapters on general obligations and on accounting and audit now apply by status, to Islamic Financial Institutions and firms operating an Islamic Window (IFR 3.1.1 and 4.1.1). Old chapter 2, which was all guidance, is deleted, and so is the guidance on investment and crypto tokens. Fund offers drop out of IFR 1.1.1; new guidance points to CIR Part 7 for offers of Units in Islamic Domestic Funds.

Next up, Takaful disclosure moves house. The four extra disclosures for Takaful proposed to a Retail Client leave IFR chapter 8 and go back into COB as Rule 7.7.4. They cover the contracts between the fund and the operator, how the operator’s fees or profit share are worked out, how surpluses are shared, and when extra contributions may be needed. New IFR guidance says they apply whether or not the firm holds itself out as conducting Islamic Financial Business. GLO gains a definition of Takaful.

Also note that credit rating agencies get a lighter COB in places. The staff conflict rule now catches a relationship with anyone employed by the rated entity or its related party, where it may cause or be seen to cause a conflict, instead of only a close relative currently employed there (COB 8.6.3(2)). Fee arrangements go in the annual report but no longer in rating announcements, and only for entities the agency has rated (COB 8.8.2(1)). The rule on disclosing whether a structured product’s information is public is deleted (COB 8.8.3), and disclosing how structured finance ratings are differentiated becomes a “should” in guidance. The 12 hours’ notice to a rated entity before publication stays as guidance, with a new expectation that agencies consider whether 12 hours is enough.

Islamic windows and Takaful intermediaries should check their marketing against the new holding-out test before January, and move the Takaful disclosure checklist from IFR to COB.